Friday, March 15, 2019

Case of the Day: Brazell v. Uddenberg, 2019 CCA LEXIS 36 (U.S. Air Force Ct. Crim. App. Jan. 28, 2019)

Summary:

Petitioner is an Air Force soldier who filed for a writ of habeas corpus while being under custody in the Navy prison. The petitioner was imprisoned pursuant to the Japan-US Status of Forces Agreement (SOFA) with Japan, as he sexually abused a minor while being stationed in Japan. Petitioner claimed the court martial lacked subject matter jurisdiction under SOFA, because SOFA gives Japanese authorities the primary authority to exercise jurisdiction over crimes committed by US soldiers stationed in Japan.

The court rejected the claim. The court found that because both US and Japan criminalizes sexual abuse against a minor, there was no exclusive jurisdiction under SOFA. In the absence of exclusive jurisdiction, US and Japan have concurrent jurisdiction. Although Japan has the primary right to exercise jurisdiction if the jurisdiction is concurrent, Japan need not explicitly waive the primary right for US to exercise jurisdiction.

Takeaway:

US forces stationed abroad is a ripe place for seeing under-address treaty issues! Highly interesting stuff if you're into jurisdictional challenges.

4 comments:

  1. One impressive thing about Yuka App is how it educates users naturally. Instead of overwhelming information, it provides simple explanations that guide people toward healthier decisions during everyday shopping.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm thoroughly impressed by WCCMagazine and its commitment to delivering verified news daily. The diverse coverage across politics, tech, and culture keeps me well-informed. Outstanding journalism that I can truly trust!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I particularly admire how NewsMetroPolitan covers metropolitan affairs with depth and clarity. The political analysis is insightful, and technology updates are always relevant. Brilliant platform that consistently delivers!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Discovering such a credible NewsDataCenter has been invaluable for my daily routine. The writing quality, source reliability, and topic diversity are all outstanding. Thank you for this exceptional news service!

    ReplyDelete